बेबाक · Editorial
As a Bay of Bengal Cyclone Nears, States Show Readiness; the Real Test Comes After Landfall
Early warnings and closures from Kerala to Odisha are worth praising, but India needs preparedness that is measured, published and improved after each storm.
A Coast on Alert
Southern and eastern India is entering a dangerous week. The northeast monsoon has begun over Tamil Nadu, Puducherry, Karaikal, Coastal Andhra Pradesh, Rayalaseema, South Interior Karnataka, Kerala and Mahe. A weather system over the Bay of Bengal is likely to intensify into a deep depression on Sunday and a cyclonic storm by Monday morning, and some forecasts say it could become a very severe cyclonic storm. Landfall is likely between Bapatla and Visakhapatnam on October 28, with winds that weather experts say may reach 130 kmph. The India Meteorological Department (IMD) has issued red alerts for 13 districts in Andhra Pradesh on October 27 and 28. Kerala has red alerts in five districts, and schools are closed. Heavy rain and thunderstorms are being reported or forecast from Goa to Nagaland and the wider North-East.
Caution Has a Cost
The central tension is familiar. Closing schools, shutting tourist sites and restricting roads can save lives. It also costs children their school days, takes income from traders and guides, and disrupts daily work. Odisha has announced school closures and put response teams on alert. In Tamil Nadu, all tourist spots in the Nilgiris are closed, and the Coimbatore district administration has told the public to avoid the ghat roads from Mettupalayam to Udhagamandalam via Coonoor and Kotagiri, and from Pollachi to Valparai. Critics of such orders have a fair point: blanket closures can become a habit, and alerts issued too often can lose public trust. Supporters have the stronger point this week. The Coimbatore advisory was issued because major landslides had already occurred at several locations.
What the Evidence Shows
Some of this preparedness deserves recognition. The Greater Chennai Corporation has readied drones and zonal control rooms ahead of the heavy rain forecast. It is coordinating with other departments and monitoring reservoirs and waterbodies in the suburbs, including Poondi, Puzhal, Cholavaram, Kesavapuram and Thervoy Kandigai, in real time. Watching upstream waterbodies matters because what happens in the suburbs can shape how much water reaches the city. Till 8.30 a.m. on Saturday, rain had fallen at about 80 per cent of places across Tamil Nadu. Isolated places in Theni, Dindigul and Madurai districts are under red alert for extremely heavy rain. In Goa, Canacona recorded 101.6 mm of rain between 8.30 a.m. and 5.30 p.m. on Friday. The IMD issued a Pre-Cyclone Watch (Yellow Message) for Andhra Pradesh and the adjoining south Odisha coast ahead of landfall.
A Considered Verdict
State governments, district administrations and municipal bodies are acting early, as a federal system should, with the IMD providing a common forecast for all of them. That deserves praise. The postponement of the President's visit to Odisha amid the cyclone threat also appears to reflect a sensible ordering of priorities. The concern lies elsewhere. Readiness is announced loudly before a storm, but it is too rarely measured openly afterwards. Figures on how many people were evacuated on time, whether control rooms answered every call, how quickly ghat roads reopened, and how many school days were lost and recovered are seldom made easy for the public to find. Without those numbers, each cyclone season risks starting from memory rather than from evidence. A red alert is a promise from the state to the citizen. It is only kept when the roads reopen, the schools resume and the review is made public.
The Way Forward
Three steps are feasible within this season. First, every state placed under red alert this week should publish a short review within 30 days of the storm passing. It should cover evacuation numbers, response times, and damage to roads and power lines. Second, reservoir operators in Chennai and other cities should make release schedules public in real time, so that residents downstream get the same warning as the control room. Third, school closures should come with a clear plan to make up lost days, especially for children without devices at home. The IMD has given the country advance warning. Turning that warning into lasting public trust is the job of every state government and city body on the coast.
A red alert is a promise from the state to the citizen; it is only kept when the roads reopen, the schools resume and the review is made public.
What this editorial rests on
Drawn from our live multi-newsroom feed — read the reporting at source.
An editorial is the considered opinion of the Aad Tak desk, argued from the sourced reporting above and written under our published persona, बेबाक. We name institutions, not parties. If we are wrong, we will say so. How we work →